Help strengthen alternative media by visiting our supporters

Sheepdog Supplies

Bundy Dismissal is Upheld By Ninth Circuit

The govt's argument included that the definition of the term “sniper” was inaccurate for this case.

dismissal “Bad Faith!” Govt Caught Withholding Evidence – AGAIN!
Rancher Cliven Bundy, 2014. (Photo by Shannon Bushman, used with permission)

Bundy Dismissal is Upheld By Ninth Circuit

by Shari Dovale

The Bunkerville Protest Defense has tallied up another win!

When the government attempted to prosecute 19 men for their roles in the Bunkerville Protest in 2014, they were desperate. They had invested millions of dollars in the operation to impound Bundy’s cattle, and millions more in the prosecution of everyone they could round up.

Judge Gloria Navarro had shown that she was all in for the prosecution, ruling time and again against the defense. She did not allow the defendants to present much in the way of evidence, did not allow them to plead self-defense, and ruled against them if she just thought they might say the wrong thing in court.

But the prosecution got cocky and overplayed their hand.

The prosecution was caught withholding vital evidence from the defense in multiple violations of the Brady Rule. This caused Judge Navarro to be left with no choice but to declare a mistrial with prejudice, meaning the prosecution could not come back later and try to prosecute these defendants again.

The government actors went nuts, and tried everything they could to get the judge’s ruling thrown out. They seemed determined to hold as many of the Bundy defendants behind bars for the rest of their lives as possible.

The latest round was the prosecution begging the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals to throw out Judge Navarro’s ruling. This did not go well for them.

The argument from the government to the appeals court included that they believed the definition of the term “sniper” was inaccurate for this case. They described government “marksmen” in an “over-watch position”, yet stated that did not mean the men were “snipers”. However, the court found:

Yet, in the middle of Bundy’s trial, the government was producing documents that referred to its own agents as “snipers.”

The appellate court affirmed the court’s dismissal in the case and threw the ball back into the prosecution’s lap, presumable to properly dispose of it.



The views, opinions, or positions expressed by the authors and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, positions of Redoubt News. Social Media, including Facebook, has greatly diminished distribution of our content to our readers’ newsfeeds and is instead promoting Main Stream Media sources. This is called ‘Shadow-banning’. Please take a moment and consider sharing this article with your friends and family. Thank you. Please support our coverage of your rights. Donate here:

3 Comments on Bundy Dismissal is Upheld By Ninth Circuit

  1. The appeal attorney refers to a “Universal sense of Justice” ? ! ? !…Here’s more of the sick fantasy world we saw in Judge Navarro’s courtroom…Do these Govt lawyers actually believe in what they are saying ?…Those of us who witnessed this trial were aghast and appalled at the travesty being played out – No, folks, this proceeding was NOT like those we recall from old Perry Mason movies !…Navarro’s “Sense of justice” manifested itself in her disdainful attitude – she barely tolerated the defense team, while working hand in glove with the prosecution..At one point she even allowed a prosecutor to throw personal insults at the defense lawyers !..If a sense of justice resides anywhere in this country, it resides in us, in our own hearts..Hopefully, we will consult the Better Angels of Our Nature when our turn comes to see that justice is served…

    • Shade Tree…You must be thinking of Lavoy’s ambush and assassination..His wife, Jeanette, has lodged a wrongful death suit, and after FOUR YEARS the court has finally granted permission for the suit to proceed..As one of the Malhure accused, we saw the govt go into overdrive to hang us..”Time’s a wastin’ “…”.Cost is no object”…”Go ! Go ! Go !…and we were tried – and acquitted – within the year…But an accusation against the Govt ? Say What ?…oh ! that takes forever !

Comments are closed.