Help support alternative media by visiting our Allies

Selkirk Mountain Real Estate

Medicaid Expansion Marches Forward in Montana

The Republican (in name only) sponsored bill HB658 beat out the democratic version of Medicaid Expansion in the House of Representatives.

Medicaid Expansion Marches Forward in Montana
Photo: Tim Ravndal/Redoubt News

Medicaid Expansion Marches Forward in Montana

By Tim Ravndal

The people of Montana have been wondering how Medicaid Expansion (HB658) has made it in the Montana Legislature with so many unanswered questions.  The primary sponsor of the bill is Republican Representative Edward Buttery from Great Falls Montana.

Representative Buttery serves on the board of directors of the Benefis Hospital in Great Falls.  His association on the board has been questioned as a conflict of interest but no action has been moved against Mr. Buttery on the claim.  The Hospital has been at the center of a “certificate of public advantage” (COPA) legal battle since 1996.  Outside competition to provide health care in Great Falls has been systematically eliminated by the corporate actions.

Representative Buttery brought HB658 to the table one week after the people of Montana voted down I-185  back in November of 2018.  About the same time according to the position of the Republican Party in Montana, Medicaid Expansion was was given a failing grade.

Republican Representative Edward Buttery

In March of this year HB658 was made available to the full legislature and the public.

The republican sponsored legislation has garnered additional republican sponsorship from Representatives Fred Anderson, Duane Ankney, Nancy Ballance, Geraldine Custer, Julie Dooling, Ross Fitzgerald, Steve Fitspatrick, Rodney Garcia, Frank Garner, Terry Gauthier, Bruce Grubbs, Ken Homlund, Brian Hoven, Llew Jones, Joshua Kassmier, Denley Loge, Wendy Mckamey, Fred Moore, Tom Richmond, Walt Sales, Dan Saloman, Ray Shaw, Jason Small, Russel Tempel, Jeff Welborn and Tom Welch.

HB658 beat out the democratic version of Medicaid Expansion in the House of Representatives brought forward by Representative Mary Caffero and Montana Governor Steve Bullock.

The bill failed to get support from the members of the Senate Health & Safety Committee and was tabled.  This last Friday, Senator Jason Small made a motion from the floor of the full Senate to force the bill out of committee.

According to Senate President Senator Scott Sales, not a single member of the Senate objected to the motion made by Senator Small.  Because there is no objection to the motion there is no vote called.  Without an objection, all 50 Montana Senators through silence voted to advance the bill in the Senate.

Senators that pledged to vote against the legislation from the beginning remained silent on the motion.

The motion made was to bring the legislation before the Senate Finance and Claims Committee.  The testimony on the bill before the finance and claims committee was limited to the fiscal note on the bill.

Republican Senator Bob Keenan brought forward legal and fiscal concerns.  Senator Keenan is the sole member of the committee that brought forward a challenge to the legislation.

Republican Senator Bob Keenan

The Senate committee after hearing from supporters of the legislation closed the hearing and went straight to taking “Executive Action” on HB658.

Senator Olszewski brought forward a motion before the committee to amend the bill to remove the funding mechanism founded in the Workers Compensation Fund.  Removing the revenue from the fund placed multiple funding questions back on the table.

The committee voted on the amended bill and narrowly passed HB658 with a 10 to 9 vote.  Republican Senators Duane Ankney, Mike Cuffe, Dan Soloman all voted for Medicaid Expansion.

The legislation will now continue on the fast track and be scheduled for 2nd Reading before the full Senate.  There the Senators of Montana will have another chance to follow the majority vote of the people against Medicaid Expansion in Montana.


The views, opinions, or positions expressed by the authors and those providing comments are theirs alone, and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, positions of Redoubt News. Social Media, including Facebook, has greatly diminished distribution of our stories to our readers’ newsfeeds and is instead promoting Main Stream Media sources. This is called ‘Shadow-banning’. Please take a moment and consider sharing this article with your friends and family. Thank you. Please support our coverage of your rights. Donate here:

3 Comments on Medicaid Expansion Marches Forward in Montana

  1. I understand that on April 15 there will be a Freedom Rally in Helena MT at the capital. I think a sign with the names of these ______(fill in the blank) who are supporting Medicaid Expansion even after the people voted it down, would be in order. Thank you Redoubt News for giving us that list.

Comments are closed.